OVERTURES FROM FINLAND, Oulu Sinfonia, Rumon Gamba/Chandos
Finnish music seems to be finally coming into its own, and this beautifully played and recorded disc will accelerate that process. There are familiar pieces here (e.g. Sibelius’ Karelia) alongside much that will be new to most listeners, but the Oulu Sinfonia under Rumon Gamba have created a fascinatingly organic program with a selection of music that is both rigorously structured and winningly accessible. It’s to be hoped that the Oulu Sinfonia and Gamba might be able to carry this particular Finnish trick off a second time.
TCHAIKOVSKY: SYMPHONY NO. 5, Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, Manfred Honeck/Reference Recordings Classical CD Choice’s own Graham Williams has already extolled the virtues of this remarkable performance, and his was an early harbinger of the slew of equally enthusiastic reviews to follow — to which, I can now add my own encomium. Apart from the breathtaking commitment of the performance (hardly unexpected, as that is the sine qua non of the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra and conductor Manfred Honeck), there is the impactful recording, couched in Reference Recordings’ characteristically wide-ranging sound. The Tchaikovsky is coupled with Erwin Schulhoff’s Five Pieces, impressively arranged for large orchestra by Manfred Honeck and Tomáš Ille.
WRANITZKY: ORCHESTRAL WORKS, Czech Chamber Philharmonic Orchestra Pardubice, Marek Štilec/Naxos Will the day ever come when there are no longer new discoveries to be made for the adventurous classical listener? It would seem not, and here is something else to tickle the ear of the novelty seeker. Wranitzky’s highly individual sound world is extremely distinctive, and this welcome disc demonstrates not only Wranitzky’s compositional diversity but a penchant for careful symphonic strategies. The Czech Chamber Philharmonic Orchestra Pardubice perform confidently under the baton of Marek Štilec.
MARTINŮ, RAUTAVAARA: PIANO CONCERTOS NO. 3, Olli Mustonen, piano Lahti Symphony Orchestra, Dalia Stasevksa/BIS SACD What a wonderful disc! You may possess individual recordings of these winning pieces, but as assembled here, they make an immensely cherishable collection – and in splendid SACD sound. Needless to say, the concertos are better listened to individually, but these are matchless readings. The Czech Bohuslav Martinů and the Finn Einojuhani Rautavaara are perfect disc companions. Rautavaara noted that, as a Finn, he stands ‘between East and West, between the tundra and Europe, between Lutheran and Orthodox faith’.
RODGERS & HAMMERSTEIN: OKLAHOMA!, soloists, John Wilson//Chandos SACD It’s hardly surprising that John Wilson’s conducting of the complete Rodgers and Hammerstein score for Oklahoma! is exemplary – but the real revelation here is the restoration of the original Robert Russell Bennett orchestrations; Wilson’s attention to detail makes it clear why Rodgers regarded Bennett as such a key collaborator. However, for most listeners, it will not be Bennett’s wonderful orchestrations that are the principal attraction here but the glorious Rodgers and Hammerstein score heard in its entirety – and sounding quite as fresh as it did back in 1945 when the score transformed the face of musical theatre from a series of winning individual songs to something with a closely knit texture and genuine dramatic values. It is something of a cliché to praise John Wilson’s command of the Broadway and Hollywood idiom, but if listeners were in any need of reminding of his skills, this exemplary set will do the trick. Aficionados of the score, however, will need to hold onto the one-disc film soundtrack which remains a beautifully sung and played testament to this durable score.
BEETHOVEN: PIANO TRIOS, VOL. 2, OP. 1/2 & 97 ‘ARCHDUKE’, Sitkovetsky Trio/BIS SACD The debate as to who is the greatest of all classical composers will continue for as long as music is listened to, but for those for whom Beethoven is supreme, here is yet another recording to be adduced to their argument. Is there a composer who is so utterly triumphant in whatever field he turned his hand to? Such musings are prompted by these remarkable performances of Beethoven’s piano trios, which, musical values apart, are granted a typically wide-ranging recording in surround sound, a hallmark of the BIS label.
STÖHR: ORCHESTRAL MUSIC VOL. 2, Sinfonia Varsovia, Ian Hobson/Toccata This is music of character which repays repeated listenings — advisable, given that the scores here do not offer up their secrets at the first hearing. But as the earlier volume in this series demonstrated, Richard Stöhr is a composer of merit to whom of attention must be played. The music of the Austro-American Stöhr offers much of interest, with the first of his two suites for string orchestra sporting an eloquent slow movement with reminiscences of Bruckner, Mahler and Franz Schmidt .
SANTORO: SYMPHONY NO. 8; CELLO CONCERTO, Denise de Freitas, Marina Martins, Goias Philharmonic. Orchestra, Neil Thomson/Naxos It’s intriguing to note that a composer who enjoyed much press attention in his lifetime could fade so thoroughly from public view – as is the case with Claudio Santoro. But the Naxos label has a history of dusting off careers that have languished, and this welcome series is doing precisely that for the talented Santoro.. The plangent sound of his Cello Concerto reflects his experiences in East Berlin as construction started on the Berlin Wall. The powerful Eighth Symphony combines serial techniques with Expressionist characteristics.
JANACEK: KREUTZER SONATA, INTIMATE LETTERS; HAAS: FROM THE MONKEY MOUNTAINS, Escher String Quartet, Colin Currie/BIS SACD Recordings of orchestral transcriptions of Janacek’s remarkable string quartet inspired by Tolstoy’s story The Kreutzer Sonata have made a persuasive case for the piece in its enhanced guise, but that hardly obviates the need for distinguished new performances of the work in its original quartet form. Particularly readings as personal and full of character as here – what’s more, the Escher String Quartet do similar justice to the Haas piece, From the Monkey Mountains, a chamber composition that has also enjoyed orchestral transcription. Leoš Janáček’s first quartet, subtitled ‘Kreutzer Sonata’, has as its subject marriage, adultery and murder, all conjured by the composer. ‘From the Monkey Mountains’, according to its composer, describes ‘pleasant summer holidays in the country’, but jolts the listener in the final movement, entitled ‘A Wild Night’, when percussion is added to the string quartet, played here by the Scottish virtuoso Colin Currie.
TOPOS – 20TH-CENTURY GREEK ORCHESTRAL MUSIC, Noé Inui, Thessaloniki State Symphony Orchestra, Zoi Tsokanou/Naxos The listener may not be familiar with too many pieces by Greek-Cypriot composers, but this enterprising collection should go some way towards redressing that situation. Solon Michaelides’s evocative Dawn at the Parthenon utilises impressionist tropes, while Manolis Kalomiris, a key talents in Greek national music, evokes Rimsky-Korsakov in his Island Pictures. Yannis Constantinidis’s two suites are notable for their subtle dance rhythms and expert orchestration, while Nikos Skalkottas’s ingenious Greek Dances, one of his most popular works, is heard here in an edition for string orchestra by his friend, the conductor and composer Walter Goehr.
BRUCKNER: SYMPHONY NO. 7, Londo Symphony Orchestra, Simon Rattle/LSO Live It is to be hoped that listeners make the most of Simon Rattle’s distinguished period with the London Symphony Orchestra as he makes his way to other shores. Whatever the reason for his departure (perhaps the frustration at not being granted the new concert hall that at one point appeared to be within his grasp, before organisational plans were changed), Rattle is still one of the great modern conductors – and this new reading of Bruckner’s imposing Seventh Symphony is among the most striking readings of late romantic masterpiece yet committed to disc, with LSO on bravura form.
SOUNDS AND SWEET AIRS – A SHAKESPEARE SONGBOOK, Carolyn Sampson, Roderick Williams, Joseph Middleton/BIS SACD Sounds and Sweet Airs – A Shakespeare Songbook utilises the talents of Carolyn Sampson, Roderick Williams and Joseph Middleton, working with the 37 songs in this recital, written by 27 composers, set to the words of Shakespeare. Non-pareil vocalising.
BACH: ORGAN WORKS 4, Masaaki Suzuki/BIS SACD Volume 4 of Masaaki Suzuki’s Bach works for organ continues the high standards set by its predecessors, and these masterpieces of the organ repertoire are couched in a picture that is both analytical in its detail and dramatic in its diaphragm-shaking lower register. The success of the performances owes much to the organ utilised here, one of the most important surviving instruments of Bach’s time, made by the German organ builder Christoph Treutmann the Elder. A recent general restoration preserved all essential structural elements or renewed them, remaining faithful to the originals, making it an ideal instrument for Bach interpreters who wish to come close to the sound ideas of the Leipzig Thomaskantor. Suzuki now takes up the Orgel-Büchlein (little organ book).
MOZART: SYMPHONIES NUMBERS 39 & 40, Norwegian Radio Orchestra, Petr Popelka/LAWQ When the catalogues contain so many recordings of these late Mozart symphonies, something special is required to justify new takes on these masterpieces. If the Norwegian Radio Orchestra under Petr Popelka don’t quite unseat earlier classic takes, they provide sympathetic and musicianly readings.
NOSKOWSKI: SYMPHONIES 1&2. DSRP, Antoni Wit/Capriccio The composer Zygmuts Noskowski (whose dates are 1846 – 1909) is an extremely capable and accomplished musician, if not quite of the first rank – which might account for his neglect for over a century. Nevertheless the conductor Antoni Wit demonstrates throughout this interesting set that he has the measure of the composer’s unusual idiom, and a strong case is made for these two little-known symphonies.
ATTERBERG: ALADDIN soloists SB/Jonas Albert/CPO In recent years, listeners have warmed to the extremely attractive symphonies of Kurt Atterberg, recordings which have brought the music out of the shadows from which they have languished too long. Those already under Atterberg’s spell will need little persuasion to sample his extremely accessible opera Aladdin, which is given a performance that makes the best possible case for the piece. Not all of the singers here are of the first rank, but there are no weak links in the cast, and the conducting of Jonas Albert pulls everything together with great assurance.
DORNAN: SIKLON, Boston Modern Orchestra Project, Gil Rose/BMOP The Boston Modern Orchestra Project celebrates its 20th anniversary season with this enterprising issue. Israeli American composer Avner Dornan is an experienced and inventive composer for large orchestra, and this collection of five of the composer’s orchestral works offers an overview of his satisfying and unusual music, couched in the customary sympathetic BMOP surround sound.
